The following Old Colony student-athletes have been selected to the Softball Mayflower League All-Star Team for this past season:
- Yahaira Robles-Ferro (Rochester)
- Mari Mitchell (Lakeville)
The following Old Colony student-athletes have been selected to the Mayflower League Baseball All-Star Team for this past season:
- Nathan Deree (Acushnet)
- Alexander Mitchell (Lakeville)
- Christopher Faustino (Rochester)
All-Star selections are made by the Mayflower League coaches.